Is it right or wrong that fifteen students with AIDS were admitted to college and did not disclose their status upon enrollment?
I remember a video about a mother who hid her AIDS and took her child to a normal hospital and the doctor was infected...
Then the woman and her husband righteously said they were justified, forced by the colored eyes of society, and had to be, and the doctor said they had to recommend a visit to the CDC first, and then take precautions before they could be seen, and that the doctor had the right to know.
In the same way, I don't necessarily discriminate against you when I know about your illness, but I definitely pay attention to it, there's no way around it, it's human nature, and I have the right to protect myself, as everyone does.
Everyone thinks that people with AIDS are weak and vulnerable, no, I just think the opposite that people with AIDS are a strong group because of their own power of attack, there are some AIDS patients who are vindictive to society will choose to promiscuous, crazy infected with the virus, and there are also some infected will be similarly vindictive to society.
This is the strong group, on the contrary, uninformed people are vulnerable, because there is no corresponding resistance, even if infected, there is no corresponding legal rights, moreover, there is no way to judgment, in the absence of sufficient legal weapons to be able to protect their own situation, this is a very embarrassing thing, perhaps the transmission channels are not so widespread, but the prevention of people can not be avoided.
I've seen a lot of people with Hepatitis B who are internally unbalanced will tamper with other people's meals (spit), it's all about the heart and not all people with the disease will accept the status quo.
On the contrary I wish those who have contagious diseases would empathize with an ordinary person, everyone has their own family, parents, wife, children and grandchildren.
It is not the diseased that we ostracize, but the fear of the unknown and the human heart, thank you!
I do not discriminate against them. College students they live in the school is a collective life, usually with them in class together to learn no problem, but together with the accommodation and food problems come to the fore. Several students in the dormitory will often get together for meals, is this safe? Although AIDS is mainly transmitted by sexual transmission and blood transmission, the bumps in life will have it, in case of accidental bleeding was infected, there is no danger? Think about it differently: are you willing to eat, drink and sleep with them? There is also the most important point, nowadays college students in the school dating sex has been a high probability of events, in case they do not inform each other and have sex, the other party is infected with a high chance. And how the rate of growth of sexual transmission on campus is alarming. The right to life outweighs the right to privacy at all times, and you protect the right to privacy of students with AIDS, but then you violate the right of your classmates to be safe and informed. So for the school about not disclosing their status is indeed wrong.
One that screams that college students are in jeopardy of beating their principals and teachers to death, let's take a peek at reality.
First, the current status of AIDS
Beijing 2016 AIDS infected 3135 people, this is the light Beijing, I think more than a bunch of uneducated black black Guangzhou number of people is estimated to be several times. That is to say the fact that around you and me AIDS is not a legendary disease, you may eat at the same table with AIDS patients in life, play ball together, watch movies.
The three ways AIDS is spread: breast milk, blood, and sex
1, breast milk needless to say the children of AIDS patients cure rate is extremely high, but not absolutely, of course, this is not discussed here, interested in their own Baidu.
2, blood transmission is a common mode of transmission of AIDS, blood transfusion, accidental surgery, etc., please note that AIDS through blood transmission requires a certain amount and within a certain period of time, the HIV virus in the air survival time is very short, a few seconds will begin to die, at most, only a few minutes of survival. So unless you two play blood oaths and such theater, otherwise basically want to spread through the blood is unlikely.
Mosquito bites do not spread AIDS, mosquito blood sucking is a one-way street, it will not back spit the AIDS blood into your blood, and the mosquito caliber on the blood donation is too small, there are scientific reports that is about 0.00004 milliliters, you need to bite back and forth repeatedly on a single wound more than 2800 to reach the dose of transmission, and mosquito bites secreted anti-thrombin is effective in killing HIV, you Even if you slap a mosquito full of blood, the blood is only on the surface of your body and can not enter your blood circulation.
3, sexually transmitted, I really want to say that if everyone in the world can wear a condom for 20 years, AIDS is basically extinct, once again, with your college students in the school caution: to wear a condom! Wear a condom! Wear a condom! Can you not play so open Oh, good to protect themselves, with a good condom is not a big problem. Even if there is no such danger you should also consider the accidental pregnancy thing, really need to clean yourself well.
Truth be told, I'm tempted to say this principal did a great job! Why?
First, it's not some superficial thing where you don't do shit to earn a political record, he must have done more and prepared more than you can imagine when he made this decision.
Secondly, I believe that with these fifteen time bombs on campus, several major campus problems will be greatly abated, such as school bullying, unplanned pregnancies of current college students, and the carts of green tea and mineral water at the entrance of the campus... Do you know that there are fifteen unidentified AIDS patients in your school, and do you dare to go without a condom? I'm sure it's very pure in this school for four years 😇.
Third, in fact, this behavior is really in line with the essence of education: guide people to the good, 15 college entrance exams AIDS carriers were rejected, so exiled into society, I believe that the possibility of retaliation against the community than to stay on campus, reasonable psychological counseling coupled with the popularization of relevant health knowledge, can make this group of students feel the care of society and the warmth, which is education, rather than a group of middle school students think that they are the center of the world all to serve the flowers of our motherland, this childish idea. Instead of letting a group of secondary school students think that they are the center of the world and that everyone has to serve us, the flowers of the motherland, this kind of childish thinking.
Sex education and AIDS prevention education really do not do the surface work, you really care so much about safety issues, should not always just emphasize the environment of comfort, more should go to learn safety knowledge and strengthen their own, I really hope that now the younger siblings can really stand up to the height of the knowledge of college students can match up with the height of the spirit should not be from the campus out of the selfishness of the human spirit that is the future pillar of the community! The future pillars of society.
One last thing, people are herd animals, a little more care and understanding, don't drive people to their deaths, like what happened in Busan Row, you always end up paying for your selfishness when you turn away people who need help because of your selfishness.
Plus haha, in case you accidentally get anally raped by your AIDS hating roommate, or you get drunk and messed up worrying about winning the bidding, there's another dose of medicine that might be able to save you called a blocking pill, it works for 72 hours, the sooner the better (same rhythm as birth control pills haha), and ergo it's best not to be on that pill.
------------------------ I'm the dividing line ----------------------------
A lot of people in the comments are emphasizing their fears, so I'm going to lay out my point of view here.
Fear comes from two sources:menacing和uncharted. Not coincidentally, AIDS has it all:Covertness of transmissionpeaceVery high lethalityas well as to itsLack of knowledge。
HIV is a fragile RNA virus that can die in seconds to minutes if exposed to air, depending on the amount of virus present. HIV is inherently fragile and cannot be exposed to air, and most HIV infections are transmitted in closed environments such as blood vessels (blood transfusions/sharing of needles, etc.), vaginal or anorectal environments (e.g., condomless vaginal or anal sex), and through the presence of latents. Transmission in blood, semen, vaginal fluid, breast milk, etc., excluding saliva, sweat, urine or other body fluids. In general, kissing does not cause HIV infection. --------- Extracted from Wikipedia
Source Wikipedia
Substantively, the main and most threatening means of transmission arebloodBecause of the fragility of the anal mucosa, it is very easy to break and see blood, which is why homosexuality is easy to spread, and women also have special times, so cleanliness is the best protection.
I haven't touched any other blood in my four years of college, let alone touching someone else's blood with my own wounds, and now that you know there are AIDS patients at your school, would you still touch someone else's blood or have sex with someone without protection?
As college students, you are at the forefront of society's basic knowledge base, and if you all can't protect yourselves with knowledge, do you really want to push this group of people out into society and leave the unsuspecting underclass to deal with it?
It really feels like overkill. Society nowadays emphasizes too much on populism to the detriment of the rights of the general public. The society nowadays emphasizes too much on populism to the detriment of the rights of the general public. It preaches too much on respecting minority groups without thinking about the public. This is to protect the privacy of the 15 AIDS patients, but does it jeopardize the right to information of all other students and teachers?
Although the main means of transmission of AIDS is three, daily contact with the infection is difficult, but does not absolutely exclude the infection ah, Chinese nurses in aid of Africa do not wear masks do not protect the situation but do not dare to do artificial respiration for the locals, there is a chance of infection with AIDS. And in the case of unawareness, in case of heterosexual or homosexual relations with them how to do?
This is like the US election, too populist, deliberately appeasing gays, black groups and arms dealers in pursuit of votes, we should not learn from it. Please, when the university makes this decision, it would be wise to hold a referendum to see if the general public, students and faculty, would accept the withholding of information about AIDS? Is it acceptable to live with 15 people with AIDS around you and not even know who they are? Will this cause panic and social instability, think twice!
Let's start by replicating a portion of the message about the spread of AIDS first.
HIV is mainly found in the body fluids (such as blood, semen, vaginal secretions, breast milk, etc.) of infected people and patients, and in a variety of organs, and it can be transmitted through the exchange of HIV-containing body fluids or organ transplantation. There are 3 main ways of HIV transmission. The first one is blood transmission, and the most important blood transmission is blood transfusion; the second one is sexual contact transmission, including heterosexual contact and homosexual contact; and the third one is mother-to-child transmission. (Link to this text https://m.youlai.cn/video/mip/266251.html)
Today, we actually talk about AIDS. I don't know if you remember an episode in Wolf War II, when the people in the factory knew that Leng Feng had an infectious disease, all of them drove him away with silence. Even when the main female character says, one at a time, "I'm ashamed of you all."
However, such is human nature, and to be honest, this was one of the episodes that silenced me the most in the entirety of Battlefront II. I put myself in the shoes of a man who couldn't have come out on top.
The same is true for our treatment of AIDS.
Talk about AIDS, color change vibration fear. It may even be so exaggerated that if he looks at you, you have AIDS.
Just like in Wolf War II, the heroine and the little black girl, following Cold Front, weren't fine?
In fact, the chances of being infected with HIV are relatively low as long as you take proper precautions. But knowing this doesn't mean not worrying about it. The psychological impact of the disease is actually greater than the threat of infection. People are more worried about what if he's right next to me? What if I accidentally catch it?
Honestly, the chances of these what-ifs are small, but it's still a real possibility. That's why I see people in the Q&A talking about withdrawal drama. Because in life, we're all safe by default. Even if we don't have much safety.
And the presence of these dozen or so college students exacerbated this sense of insecurity, keeping the nerves taut at all times. As you can imagine, this class of college students, especially the third and second years, well, it's a bit stressful.
However, we should also put our minds at ease once we understand the transmission routes. AIDS, after all, is not as scary as it is said to be.
Also, whatever the illness, it does not prevent the right to education, and there should also be a right to privacy that belongs to him. There is nothing really wrong with this section of students who get into college and do not disclose their status. It is not their fault that they have AIDS. They have no choice. But can we imagine that if they do disclose their status, can they be able to study normally in the university?
No way.
One can imagine such a picture, if ever made public.
① So-and-so is an AIDS patient, and he will be attending today's open class. The teacher calls the Registrar's Office, "I have something to do today, can you arrange for someone to substitute for the class."
Students simply skipped class.
Finally only so-and-so was left to arrive at the classroom and see a suspension notice.
② It is said that so-and-so usually eats at the so-and-so cafeteria, and then ...... that cafeteria collapses because no one goes there anymore.
③ Moumou was scolded by his classmates, he then wiped the sweat on his body on his classmates, and then his classmates were so scared that they immediately went to the medical examination.
Exaggerated? Not exaggerated in the slightest, and it might even be scarier.
So by not disclosing it, it's more likely that they'll be able to participate in their studies in a more normalized manner. It also ensures that the schools they attend, function in a more normal posture.
I suggest that schools must be aware of the situation of this group of students, and although they do not make it public, some necessary safeguards must be put in place by the schools to avoid unnecessary consequences.
Otherwise, assuming he's in a relationship with a normal person, this consequence ...... might be too much.
In addition, this group of students who are patients should have the professional mindset and common sense to avoid the possibility of creating a transmission pathway while ensuring their normal academic life.
It's not our choice to be sick, but we should choose to make this disease, end from us.
We respect everyone who gets ahead through hard work, but we can't talk about respect, but we should practice it with practice, and educate in a way that protects everyone from harm.
Feel free to follow me or leave a comment to discuss and give your opinion.
This matter can be looked at in two ways.
From the perspective of students with AIDS, it is important to protect their privacy. After all, there are still misconceptions and discrimination against AIDS in society, which can easily affect the mentality of these students.
However, from the point of view of ordinary students, suddenly saying that the campus has accepted students with AIDS and will not disclose their names will inevitably cause panic and everyone will be at risk, which will affect their daily interpersonal interactions.
There are just three ways of spreading AIDS: mother-to-child transmission, sexual transmission, and blood transmission.
And these students are infected because of mother-to-child transmission, but can take medication to reduce the probability of transmission and the probability of illness, many are only carriers of the virus infected, and those who really have AIDS are still a minority. Otherwise they wouldn't be on campus to study.
However, discrimination against AIDS still exists in society, and although relevant knowledge has also been popularized on campus, students are inevitably afraid of this incurable disease. This makes it all the more necessary to provide health and safety education.
I think the reason for the students' concern is that they don't know when they have made contact with an AIDS student, and in case the area of the wound comes into contact with the blood of an AIDS student, they don't know when they have been infected, and they can't talk about taking precautions in advance.
Therefore, in response to this, I think that in addition to stepping up efforts in popularizing science and health and safety education, schools should also have dedicated staff to follow up the situation of these special students, whether they have been injured or whether they have had sexual intercourse, and so on. In particular, the personal morality of these sick students should be strengthened, so that they will pay attention to whether they have bloodstained mouths and whether they have taken safety measures when interacting with others, and so on.
All human beings are born equal and no one should be discriminated against. But everyone must also be protected in the safest way possible, so it is important that more effort be made on the part of the school to safeguard the legal rights of both special and ordinary students as far as possible.
❤Magic City Petty City Life Guide, bring you to live a petty life with attitude~ Come follow my headline!
People living with HIV also have the right to education and university;
No one has the right to publicize the privacy of HIV-infected people to the community.
So it's right that the university accepts such kids and protects their privacy.
The reason for the debate is that the pressure comes from those who are not infected. Those students who need to live in the same dorm rooms, eat in the same cafeteria, and maybe even fall in love and have sex with these infected students.
While everyone knows that eating together, shaking hands, attending classes, and talking face-to-face will not infect you with HIV, it can make many people uncomfortable if they are surrounded by potentially infected people. However, this is not something that school administrators need to worry about, and with the increase in scientific knowledge about AIDS, it can't hurt;
However, accidental sharing of razors, blood contact in unexpected situations, and unprotected sex can make campus a less reliable place.
What's the best way to do it?
In the case of receiving and not releasing information about students with HIV, the university has to do two things:
1. All students should have the concept of hygiene, not to abuse the sharing of personal belongings, and in addition must develop a healthy concept of sexuality and sexual health awareness, scientific knowledge and know the use of condoms;
2. Arrange for specialized personnel to carry out education and moderate follow-up services for those infected students, rather than management. Allow these students to carry out normal social interactions with people around them under the premise of some restraint, of course, if it involves the issue of love, sex, must be educated to the point, after all, people are mobile, restrain themselves, is responsible for more people.
Liao Shen famous doctors, heart only for your health! What to do if you are a college administrator?
谢邀.
Regarding the non-disclosure of the status of students with AIDS.I don't think it can be measured in terms of right or wrong.
in the first placeThe non-disclosure of the status of students with AIDS is intended to protect their legal rights and interests, which is a good safeguard for their right to study, make friends and live.
This is very much in their favor. These students are transmitted from mother to child, they are not at fault per se, and it is also believed that most of them will not go out to retaliate against society, but that does not exclude a small number of them.
I believe that most people do not discriminate against AIDS patients, and they understand the feelings of AIDS patients and are willing to lend a helping hand.
But for other students, who should pay for their legitimate rights and interests?
Having said that, there will surely be many people who will want to tell me about the ways in which AIDS is transmitted.
Needless to say we all know thatHIV is transmitted through mother-to-child, blood, and sex. Normal daily interactions do not transmit HIV.
But here's what I'm asking:Can you guys guarantee that they will be able to socialize properly?
Will the following happen?
1, fall in love. University career is the most active time of youth, but also the most eager to fall in love, so in the university life is a very common thing to fall in love.
People living with HIV are no exception. They are in their youthful years and they long for love. So will they deliberately hide their disease because they want to fall in love with someone, leading to the infection of the person they fall in love with?
2. In university dormitories, dormitory friction is a very common thing. If on a certain day AIDS students have a verbal altercation with their roommates, the kind ones are fine, and if they meet the extreme ones and develop a retaliatory mentality, will the other students be in danger?
3, in the case of not open to the sick students in the university to make good friends, but one day the sick students injured, good friends because of concern in the case of unknowingly touched the patient's blood, and in this regard infected, and his good friends and what to do?
So, I think those who are infected with HIV through mother-to-child transmission need protection, but the vast majority of ordinary students need even more protection. They need the right to know, in order to safeguard their own safety. Although they know about AIDS, who can guarantee their safety?
所In order to do so, I think the best way is to inform students in advance, so that they can be psychologically prepared, and then supplemented by knowledge education, and over time, we will slowly accept it.
At the same time, I also hope that we can also give them more love and care and not discriminate against them, because they are also unfortunate, and I believe that our love and care is also a good protection for us, after all, no one wants to hurt a person who loves him or her.
More opinions in the "phantom harmony" oh! Please like and follow me!
I think this is a disguised way of provoking the society at large to discriminate against and reject people with AIDS, if the country's good teenagers have to worry about being infected with AIDS every day, don't excuse that it's fine if you don't have sex, the problem is that AIDS is not only spread through the way of sexual behavior either, so I feel that wanting to uphold the so-called human rights but sacrificing the human rights of more people by not letting people with AIDS to enter the ordinary colleges and universities to study, even though there's a feeling of tyranny of the majority, however! In my humble opinion, allowing them to attend specialized schools would be a better way to love them!
If you don't believe me, ask Heshen to comment on it! (҂‾ ▵‾)︻デ══1
I believe that not disclosing the status of the 15 students with AIDS is detrimental to the safety of normal students at the University!
We all understand: caring for people living with HIV, treating them equally and kindly!
But while caring for this group of people, it is also important to care for normal people to protect themselves from HIV!
Fifteen HIV-positive university students proudly entered university and started a new chapter in their lives! This is an uplifting message and a positive force for other negative people living with HIV! The reason for not disclosing their status is to protect and care for them, and to avoid discrimination against them! So the question is: Do normal college students have the right to know the status of HIV patients?
These 15 HIV-positive college students will not say that they are carriers of the virus themselves, and do the surrounding college dormitory roommates have the right to know the status of HIV-positive college students?
Two of the ways in which HIV is transmitted are through blood and urine! The urine of a person with HIV may also contain HIV, preventing contact with body fluids, including blood!
College dormitory roommates, may not pay attention to hygiene, or there will be a small accident cut bleeding, there will also be small friction, will there be blood contact? For example, if a student with HIV accidentally cuts his finger and bleeds, and his dormitory roommate helps to stop the bleeding out of concern, and it so happens that this enthusiastic roommate has a wound on his hand? Will he or she be infected with HIV somehow?
HIV is also spread by "sharing razors and toothbrushes."
Razors, toothbrushes, etc. used by people living with HIV can also be infected with AIDS! If you share these items with them, there is a possibility of contagion!
It is also common for college students to share razors with each other, especially with their dormitory mates, so the question arises: if everyone is a normal, healthy person, sharing is not impossible! But when a healthy roommate uses a razor belonging to an HIV-positive student without his or her knowledge, what if the HIV-positive student's face is stained with blood from his or her last shave, and then the next healthy roommate is infected with the virus by accident?
Sexual transmission of HIV is known to be the most important route!
The lack of sexual knowledge and the lack of condom use among college students greatly increases the chances of infection! And who can guarantee that HIV patients can actively take precautionary measures in advance?
In caring for college students with HIV, we are guided by the principle of equality, that patients have the right to privacy, and that normal, healthy college students should also have the right to normal protection!
Personal opinion, don't spray if you don't like it! Thank you!
This question and answer are from the site users, does not represent the position of the site, such as infringement, please contact the administrator to delete.